The Watermelon Blog Green on the outside, social justice inside
"We can do better" (Kennedy)
Richest fluency
"This is what you shall do: Love the earth and sun and the animals, despise riches, give alms to everyone that asks, stand up for the stupid and crazy, devote your income and labor to others, hate tyrants, argue not concerning God, have patience and indulgence toward the people, take off your hat to nothing known or unknown or to any man or number of men, go freely with powerful uneducated persons and with the young and with the mothers of families, read these leaves in the open air every season of every year of your life, re-examine all you have been told at school or church or in any book, dismiss whatever insults your own soul; and your very flesh shall be a great poem, and have the richest fluency not only in its words but in the silent lines of its lips and face and between the lashes of your eyes and in every motion and joint of your body." Walt Whitman
All of the western countries fighting Germany and Japan in the Second World War realized that they needed to go on a war footing to meet the enormous challenge. Many of the governments had been very slow to recognize the threat, and few had prepared (and those who had merely got themselves ready to fight the First World War again), but once hostilities were under way the activity in government, business, and in homes, was frantic.
The recognition of global warming has been as belated as the recognition that the Germans were about to invade Poland, the Japanese about to bomb Pearl Harbor. And given that failure, that dodgy intelligence about the real world, all of us now have to respond to the consequences. It doesn't mean we shouldn't persist in our demands that greenhouse gas emissions be reduced (and we should keep on promoting solar and wind energy, hybrid cars, energy conservation), but since they haven't been yet, we have to prepare for the consequences of the ignorance of foolish men and evil energy companies.
We are now at the stage of the German tanks crossing the Polish border, the Japanese planes launched from their carriers. The effects of global warming are already seriously impacting the world and are set to get much worse. There are a number of things that serious Climate War Cabinets around the world should do.
Relatively dry countries and regions that rely on irrigation to grow exotic (and profitable) crops must immediately start on a serious and urgent buy back of all irrigation licenses and undertake schemes to help both farmers and communities adjust. In the post-War(ming) world it isn't going to be possible to find enough water to make deserts bloom, and the water will be needed for other purposes.
Immediately halt wood-chipping and logging in old growth forests, and the clearing of vegetation in farming areas. But simultaneously encourage a plantation timber industry based on already cleared unviable farm lands.
Immediately pressure state and local governments to put an end to any new coastal developments, and investigate relocation of individuals and businesses already on coasts.
Put an end to all fishing activity on coral reefs, ban commercial shipping through waters above them, and seriously review tourism in those areas.
Massively invest in research and development of new farm enterprises, new crops, new livestock breeds, and put serious money into providing income to farmers protecting natural ecosystems on their farms. A massive campaign of buying back farming properties suitable for conservation activities would also commence. And it would extend the National Park systems (land and marine) and provide adequate funding for them.
Seriously invest in rail infrastructure, and plan for transport needs in a way that fully integrates rail, road, sea and air transport, in order to massively reduce energy needs in the sector.
Reinstate public ownership of water, energy and transport companies in order to effectively respond to community needs without the distorting effect of the profit motive in those essential services. And encourage individuals and companies to generate their own energy from renewable sources and feed back into the grid, and aim at making every community self sufficient in water by recycling.
Facilitate the production of basic food necessities on a local and regional basis, to reduce transport costs of food.
Look at the needs of the work force were in terms of the new war economy, and properly encourage tertiary education and retraining to again have a local manufacturing industry, specializing in renewable energy technology, fuel efficient cars, transport industries, and IT. Review Free Trade Agreements and introduce measures to prevent takeovers of local companies by overseas corporations, and the outsourcing of jobs.
Put an end to any programs of prescribed burning (or 'thinning') of forests, realising that the dual impacts of climate change and burning on forests is going to cause massive loss of biodiversity, permanent damage to forest ecosystems, and ultimately the loss of the forests themselves.
Review and reduce the mining and sale of coal.
Review and reduce airline activity.
Can you think of others?
A big disruption to the economy? Sure, war does that. Do we have a choice? Yes, the big change can happen in a planned way or in an unplanned shambles. Perhaps all the business councils and right wing think tanks who have so disastrously kept us on a business as usual course for the last ten years could put themselves to work helping, under left wing economist supervision, the transition. Redemption of sorts, I suppose.
Seems daunting? Our grandparents and great-grandparents did it in the 1940s (and a number of the measures above were also instituted then). All together now.
Check out my warnings over several years on The Watermelon Blog - 'Those who think the things I say severe, or even malicious, should just see the things I do not say.' (George Bernard Shaw).
While you’ve walked the borders between metaphor, cliché, analogy, and forced-comparison many times before, this has to be one of the most adorable efforts. “We are now at the stage of the German tanks crossing the Polish border, the Japanese planes launched from their carriers.” Eek! I better call my Aunt and Uncle in France and tell them not to give up this time! As you can probably tell, I think that the sense of urgency you’re trying to impart falls more than a little flat.
I have some other bones to pick with you, but I primarily want to address the morality you attach to global warming. Specifically, you call energy corporations “evil.” Hmmm. George Bush was mocked for calling North Korea part of an “axis of evil” when it does things like starve its own people for national pride, systematically oppresses its women, and demands worship of its god-leader under penalties ranging from jail time to death, whatever the god-leader feels like. However, you reserve the adjective (used without so much as a hint of irony to temper it) for “evil energy companies.”
I’m sorry, but are those the same energy companies that allow you to maintain this blog by typing on a computer in a well-lit room that is likely temperature-controlled? Are they the same companies that give you the fuel used to operate your farming machinery and raise sheep? Perhaps they’re the same companies that supply fuel to the emergency vehicles that carry heart-attack victims to the hospital and that then give energy to heart bypass machines and other instruments that save lives.
Well, call me old-fashioned, but I think it would be decidedly more evil to stop producing all that energy that does all that good in the name of a slow, looming, not-yet-materialized threat called “global warming” than to steadily adopt green practices without interrupting the supply of energy.
[David says - Ah Robert, welcome back, you will be pleased to know that your impassioned defence of energy companies has inspired me to write another blog, just for you. Watch this space]
[David also says - and by the way I am not in 'well-lit room that is likely temperature-controlled'. The light comes through a window, and at night a low energy single bulb lights it. The house has no air conditioning in summer, and we rarely have any heating on in winter, and when we do it is just a small stand alone electric heater. There is a solar hot water system on the roof. Our water supply comes from the rain, and our waste water goes into a hole in the ground. I will soon look at some solar panels for electricity supply. My small farm truck runs on diesel, my wife's car is what you would call a 'compact'. But certainly, the day I have a heart attack I hope the ambulance does have some fuel supplied by those public-spirited energy companies. Incidentally you must be so familiar with my blog by now that you could write my biography! I look forward to it.]
"You are a person of some interest,one comes to you and takes strange gain away." (Pound)
"I find that I can have no enjoyment in the world but the continual drinking of knowledge. I find there is no worthy pursuit but the idea of doing some good for the world." (Keats)
"nothing startles me beyond the moment. The setting sun will always set me to rights - or if a sparrow come before my window I take part in its existence and pick about the gravel." (Keats)