China Machete

Description




My Links

Danwei
Beijing Sexy Fish
Richard Spencer
China Sports Today
Haohao Report
ABC News
CNET
Crikey
Skritter
Dict.cn
Home
Site Feed
My Profile
Weblog Archives
Friends

Yikatong taken to court

A Yikatong card

 

Yesterday I saw on BTV (Beijing Television Station) that the company responsible for Yikatong has been taken to court by a second-year university student for excessive profiteering.  Yikatong is the card people use to pay for public transport and has become widely used in 2006.  To buy the card, people must first pay a ‘deposit’ of 20 yuan and then pay an adjustable amount of credit to cover public transport costs.  The use of the word ‘deposit’ is a bit strange because there is no clear indication that consumers can return the card and receive their money back. 

 

According to the television report, the production cost of each card is four yuan.  That means for each unit sold, the company responsible (a company associated with the Beijing City Government) will make an immediate profit of 16 yuan.  Considering the huge amount of people who use the card (at least one million), that stands for a lot of profit.  One of the other companies involved in Yikatong is CITIC, a large government-owned investment bank. 

 

The profit does seem excessive, so I hope the court action will prove fruitful.  During the television report, the journalist interviewed several members of the public and most seemed to think 20 yuan wasn’t too expensive.  I guess that may have been the genius of the plan, make it cheap enough for the average punter to stomach, but sell it in huge numbers to maximise profits. 

 

Report by China Youth Daily

 


Posted: 12:48 PM, 27/11/2006 in Beijing

Share on Facebook

Add Comment

To clear one thing mentioned in your post

The 20 kuai deposit will be returned to customers when they return the cards.
One of the essential arguments here is what if a customer loses his card? He will lose the 20 kuai for sure. So the three students who have sued the company think that it is better and more fair for the responsible company to charge the basic cost 4 kuai. People won't lose that much if the deposit is only 4 kuai.

Posted by Beijingfish at 2:38 PM, 28/11/2006

Link

Lawsuit

I find it difficult to believe that a court anywhere would allow a claim for "excessive profits." But, maybe because it involves the government???

www.chinalawblog.com

Posted by Anonymous at 9:16 AM, 29/11/2006

Link

No legal basis

The lawsuit has been filed by a second-year student from the University of Politics and Law. According to the report in the China Youth Daily, the student believes that the 20 yuan deposit has 'no legal basis'. I'll let the lawyers from China Law Blog figure the rest out because it's too hard for me.

Posted by zhangbohan at 12:34 PM, 29/11/2006

Link

Hospitals haven't caught on...

A recent trip to the local hospital here in Suzhou showed the system that this student seems to be looking for. Customers, ah, I mean patient, are required to purchase a hospital card for 1RMB. If the card is lost, you just buy another RMB. I heard no less than three people (in just the time I was in line) complain about this price.

Bit of a contrast. Especially because the hospital's other prices are usually exorbitant, whereas the bus is dirt cheap.

Posted by The Humanaught at 11:39 PM, 10/12/2006

Link

<- Last Page | Next Page ->