China Machete

Description




My Links

Danwei
Beijing Sexy Fish
Richard Spencer
China Sports Today
Haohao Report
ABC News
CNET
Crikey
Skritter
Dict.cn
Home
Site Feed
My Profile
Weblog Archives
Friends

Building a wenming civilisation

Today I finally remembered to have a squiz at Wenming 30 Seconds, a website that showcases all the public welfare advertising that is shown before and after the nightly news bulletin on BTV.  The ads come in the form of cartoons and promote a wenming society.  Wenming means civilised and it is often the catchphrase used by the media and government when urging people ‘to do the right thing’.  Some of the cartoons on the website promote things such as not putting rubbish into flowerpots, being careful when opening the car door and not exceeding a truck’s maximum load. 

 

Picture from Wenming 30 Seconds

 

According to the website’s introduction, a large number of viewers who watch the cartoons are children, thus explaining the cartoon-style of the advertising.  This fact, however, raises some questions about the effectiveness of the cartoons.  The cartoons are aired just before the nightly news bulletin, but how many children actually sit down and actually watch a news bulletin that is boring and full of propaganda?  (No offence Wang Qishan.)  Also, some of the content doesn’t really apply to children.  For example, how many children need to worry about overloading their truck? And why is the idea of ‘unity is strength’ used in a public welfare advertisement? 

 

Despite children being listed as the main target, I can’t help believe that the advertisements are also intended for the public at large, especially members of the public who drive overloaded trucks and throw cigarette butts in every direction but the bin.  If this is the case, then the advertisements are quite disappointing and lack effectiveness.  After growing up in Australia, I have witnessed firsthand the power of strong public welfare advertising.  ‘Do the right thing’ and ‘slip, slop, slap’ have all been etched onto my memory after campaigns raised awareness about littering and the need to apply sunscreen when outdoors.  I am well aware about the repercussions of smoking after the ‘every cigarette is doing you damage’ campaign featured pictures of lungs filled with tar.  Without doubt, there is a need in every country to have public welfare advertising. 

 

Picture from Wenming 30 Seconds.  The slogan at the bottom says 'Environmental protection is derived from small things'

 

There are some serious problems in China regarding public awareness about things such as drink driving, smoking, littering and spitting in public.  From January to September 2006, car accidents killed 65,287 people.  My gut feeling is that most of these accidents were avoidable.  In my opinion, speeding and drink driving are tolerated in China.  Some of the Wenming 30 Seconds advertisements will probably attempt to raise awareness in such areas.  I believe, however, that a public welfare advertisement presented in cartoon form does not fully convey the seriousness of such problems.  Cartoon advertisements may even worsen the problem because they make speeding and hitting old pedestrians seem like a joke.  It is time to take off the kitten gloves and start to show people what really happens when a car accident occurs. 


Posted: 12:41 PM, 26/10/2006 in China

Share on Facebook

Add Comment

totally agree

I agree with what you say, there is clearly a need for much better public safety campaigning.

I can't help thinking that the Chinese government does a lot of things like put out safety messages because that is what happens in developed societies without actually thinking it through.

It is unlikely that we will see the sort of shock tactics that we see in the west. Frankly though, anyone who regularly drives in Beijing will have seen some pretty awful accidents and if that is not enough of a shock then i doubt an advertisement will make much difference to driving standards either.

This is what happens in a society where education is spoon-feeding disguised as education. If people are taught facts, but not taught to think for themselves then when they see an accident, they just shrug and say 'oh and accident' they do not use logical thought to think 'i am glad that wasn't me, i must drive more carefully to avoid killing or being killed.'

Apart from the risk of death and injury, the two other main reasons that people drive carefully are to avoid fines and imprisonment and to avoid financial loss. With so many official cars on the road driven by important people who know someone who will get them out of trouble and where the car is owned by the work unit and will be replaced/ repaired without quibble then many just do not care about how they drive.

Posted by Chris at 7:22 PM, 26/10/2006

Link

there is still hope

I am well aware of what we have done is not enough and probably not even in a proper way. But we are still trying hard. Now the government has officially asked alcohol makers to label "Alcohol damages your health" on bottles.
I sincerely hope China will become a wenmin society.

Posted by Beijingfish at 1:09 PM, 27/10/2006

Link

Lots of hope

I am not saying that there is no hope because actually there is a lot of hope. This post is mostly about my bemusement at cartoons that seem to be pussy footing around a serious problem. I feel that if you treat people like idiots then they will act like idiots, but if you give them a bit of respect then they may take some responsibility.

Posted by zhangbohan at 1:32 PM, 27/10/2006

Link

<- Last Page | Next Page ->